Bookwitch bites #120

Bah, rubbish! And I mean google and unresponsive websites. I went looking for the link to Peter Dickinson’s essay A Defence of Rubbish and found nothing. I understand the origin is a talk from 1970, but I read about it not long ago. Unfortunately, as this rubbish stands, I can offer no link.* Sorry.

I was reminded of this when I came across another – not quite so old – piece on reading rubbish, by Clémentine Beauvais on ABBA. I don’t know how I missed it, seeing as it stirred lots of feathers, and quite rightly so. Clémentine is against, but a lot of people believe in rubbish.

So do I, although there is good rubbish and bad rubbish. I’m probably most in favour of the better stuff.

John Connolly Edgar award by David Brown

Not rubbish at all is what I can say about John Connolly’s recent Edgar Award for Best Short Story for The Caxton Private Lending Library & Book Depository. (I’ve not read it, but I very much doubt he’d win anything if it was bad. Or that John would write bad stuff.) The photo of John and Edgar is pretty appalling, however. Could almost have been taken by me, but wasn’t.

More Irish excellence with the news that Eoin Colfer is the new Laureate na nOg, which I believe means he’s their Malorie Blackman. Congratulations to Eoin, and here’s to the great work he’s bound to do, for books and reading!

Someone who definitely gets young people reading is Liz Kessler, who recently reported that there is now a fantastic screenplay of her Emily Windsnap, written by a Hollywood-based producer and an amazing scriptwriter. As Liz points out, that’s still a long way from it becoming a film, but it’s a start. We’ll be waiting!

You don’t have to wait quite as long, and there’s more certainty, for the Borders Book Festival. The programme is out now, and the festival itself will happen in five weeks’ time. Who knows, I might even make it there this year. Bring on the famous Scottish sunshine!

*Below are two screen caps of parts of what Peter said:

Peter Dickinson, A Defence of Rubbish

Peter Dickinson, A Defence of Rubbish


8 responses to “Bookwitch bites #120

  1. Oh YES to the comics under the bed instead of a spot of Croquet on the Lawn – love that insight into intellectual freedom – it’s social and cultural freedom as well.

  2. I agree, Julia. There is something special about stuff you find to read in unexpected places. You choose to read it because it is there, and not because someone told you to.
    Although one way for adults to ‘cheat’ would be to hide suitable books and wait for them to be accidentally discovered.

  3. Pingback: Now You Can Also | Star Bear Publications

  4. Not to be too fancy pants about it, but on one level, Finnegans Wake is simply the story of a hen picking her way through the rubbish heap of history. Which is, well, everything.

    I can’t claim to know much about Joyce, but I do feel fairly certain that we would have come out on the defense of rubbish side.

    Whether this is an argument for or against rubbish depends upon your feelings about Joyce, I suppose.

    Although I learned last week that this is the centenary of The Dubliners, a fact that probably counts for something.

  5. “He”, not “we”, although I am in fact in favor of rubbish as well.

  6. Finnegan’s Wake. It wasn’t exactly Joyce I had in mind, but why not? Some of today’s presidents and other leaders were once rebels.

  7. It is actually Finnegans Wake without the apostrophe, by the way. One of the many ways he had of driving everyone crazy.

  8. Oops. I thought that very thought as I apostrophed.
    Banana’s, anyone?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.